Heads up: this post contains affiliate links. If you click through them we may earn a small commission at no cost to you. We only recommend tools and services we've actually tried. Full disclosure →

Instacart is structurally different from food-delivery platforms like DoorDash and Uber Eats. As an Instacart shopper, you’re not just delivering — you’re shopping at the grocery store, picking items off shelves, handling substitutions when items are out of stock, and managing the customer relationship around their grocery list. The trade-off: per-order pay is typically higher than restaurant delivery, but each order takes longer (often 30–60 minutes vs 15–30 for restaurants). This guide walks through the signup process, the two shopper roles (full-service vs in-store), the realistic comparison with food delivery, and who Instacart actually fits.

If you’re earlier in the journey or considering DoorDash as a simpler alternative, see How to Become a DoorDash Driver.

🛒 Sign Up With Instacart →

Or compare with DoorDash for drivers

What’s in this guide

Instacart shopper vs delivery driver — the actual difference

The work itself is fundamentally different from food delivery:

Restaurant delivery (DoorDash, Uber Eats, Grubhub):

  • Pick up a sealed bag from the restaurant
  • Drive to customer
  • Drop off
  • Total time: 15–30 minutes per delivery
  • Cognitive load: low
  • Physical effort: low

Instacart shopping + delivery:

  • Drive to grocery store
  • Pick items off shelves per the customer’s list
  • Handle out-of-stock substitutions (decision-making)
  • Communicate with customer if needed
  • Check out and pay (using Instacart’s payment card)
  • Drive to customer
  • Drop off
  • Total time: 30–60 minutes per order
  • Cognitive load: high
  • Physical effort: medium (lots of walking, lifting groceries)

Per-order pay is typically higher to compensate for the longer time and cognitive demand. Whether net-hourly is better depends on your shopping speed and the orders you select.

Full-service shopper vs in-store shopper

Instacart has two shopper roles:

Full-service shopper:

  • You shop at the store AND deliver to the customer
  • Higher per-order pay
  • Independent contractor (1099)
  • Set your own hours
  • Use your own car
  • The standard Instacart role

In-store shopper:

  • You shop at the store but DON’T deliver — store staff or another shopper handles delivery
  • Lower per-order pay (no delivery component)
  • Hourly W-2 employee in some markets (varying by state and store partnership)
  • Scheduled shifts at specific stores
  • No driving required
  • Limited availability — fewer markets, fewer slots

Most Instacart shoppers are full-service. In-store shopper roles are scarcer and more like traditional part-time employment.

This guide focuses on the full-service shopper role — that’s what most prospective Instacart workers are signing up for.

Honest comparison: Instacart vs DoorDash

The honest framing for prospective shoppers:

Instacart strengths:

  • Higher per-order pay (compensates for longer time)
  • Less driving per dollar earned
  • Some shoppers prefer the structure (defined list, defined task)
  • Tip culture is generally strong (grocery shopping has higher tip averages than restaurant delivery)
  • Less weather exposure (most time is inside the store)

Instacart weaknesses:

  • Each order takes much longer (30–60 minutes)
  • Cognitive load — substitution decisions, item-finding, customer communication
  • Physical demand — walking, lifting groceries
  • Customer service friction — out-of-stock items, wrong substitutions, complaints
  • Lower order frequency in many markets
  • Steeper learning curve

DoorDash strengths:

  • Faster per-delivery (more deliveries per hour possible)
  • Simpler workflow (no shopping required)
  • More markets, more order volume
  • Lower cognitive load

The honest take: Instacart appeals to people who genuinely enjoy the shopping aspect and want a more structured task. DoorDash appeals to people who want fast, repetitive, low-cognitive-load work. Many active gig workers run BOTH — Instacart during slower DoorDash hours, or as a different income stream entirely.

Instacart shopper requirements

Per Instacart’s published policies, the requirements:

Universal:

  • Age: 18+ in most markets
  • Smartphone: iPhone or Android able to run the Instacart Shopper app
  • Social Security Number for tax reporting (full-service) or W-2 onboarding (in-store)
  • Pass background check

For full-service shoppers (most common):

  • Valid driver’s license
  • Vehicle insurance in your name
  • Vehicle in good working condition (specific year requirements vary)
  • Eligibility to work in the U.S.
  • Ability to lift 50 lbs (groceries get heavy)

For in-store shoppers:

  • May not require a vehicle (you’re working at one store)
  • Different paperwork (W-2 employment, not 1099)

For deep coverage of requirements, see Instacart Shopper Requirements.

Step-by-step: how to apply

Step 1 — Visit Instacart’s shopper signup page. Go to shoppers.instacart.com.

Step 2 — Enter basic info. Email, phone, name, ZIP code. Verify your email and phone.

Step 3 — Confirm city availability. Instacart confirms it operates in your area.

Step 4 — Choose role. Full-service shopper (default for most signups) or in-store shopper if available.

Step 5 — Personal information. Full legal name, date of birth, address.

Step 6 — For full-service, vehicle info. Make, model, year, plate.

Step 7 — Upload required documents:

  • Driver’s license (front and back)
  • Vehicle insurance declaration page
  • Selfie photo for identity verification

Step 8 — Authorize background check. Sign electronically.

Step 9 — Wait for approval. Typically 5–10 business days for full-service shopper.

Step 10 — Download the Instacart Shopper app and start receiving order offers.

How long the background check takes

Instacart’s background check timeline:

  • 5–7 business days: typical clean-record cases
  • 7–14 business days: if additional review needed
  • 14+ business days: atypical cases

Slightly longer than DoorDash and Uber Eats on average. Instacart’s process includes additional verification specific to handling payment cards (since shoppers use a payment card to pay for groceries on the customer’s behalf).

For more detail, see Instacart Background Check Guide.

What happens after approval

Once approved:

  1. Download the Instacart Shopper app
  2. Sign in with your Instacart credentials
  3. Receive your Instacart payment card in the mail (full-service shoppers — used to pay for groceries at the store)
  4. Set up payment method for your earnings — typically weekly direct deposit
  5. Take the shopper orientation — short videos covering shopping basics, substitutions, customer communication
  6. Accept your first order

The first few orders are slower as you learn — finding items, handling substitutions, managing the checkout process.

Want simpler delivery work? DoorDash is restaurant pickup only — no shopping, no decisions, just pick up and drop off. Sign up takes 10–15 minutes.

Sign Up to Dash →

How Instacart shopper pay works (high level)

Instacart’s pay model has multiple components:

  • Service fee / order pay — base pay for completing the order
  • Mileage component — per-mile rate for distance traveled
  • Quality bonus (in some markets) — extra pay for high-rated shoppers
  • Tips — 100% to shopper, customer-set
  • Peak pay / surge — multiplier during high demand
  • Heavy / large item pay — extra for large/bulky orders

For specifics on rates in your market, the Instacart Shopper app shows breakdowns. We avoid quoting specific dollar figures.

For comparison with restaurant delivery, see How DoorDash Driver Pay Works and How Uber Eats Driver Pay Works.

The multi-app strategy with Instacart

Instacart fits into the multi-app strategy differently from restaurant delivery:

The challenge: Instacart orders take 30–60 minutes. You can’t easily multi-app while in the middle of an Instacart order — you’re inside a store, or driving to a customer with groceries.

The strategy: alternate between Instacart and food delivery rather than running them simultaneously:

  • Instacart for longer scheduled blocks — accept an order, complete it, move to the next
  • DoorDash/Uber Eats during short windows — between Instacart orders or during shorter sessions

Some shoppers stay with Instacart-only because the workflow is fundamentally different from food delivery and switching contexts is mentally taxing.

For pure food delivery multi-apping, see the discussions in Is DoorDash Worth It as a Driver? and Is Uber Eats Worth It as a Driver?.

If your application is denied

If you receive an Adverse Action notice:

  1. Read it carefully — indicates the reason and your appeal rights
  2. Request the background check report — federal law gives you the right
  3. Dispute errors with the screening vendor
  4. Consider DoorDash or Uber Eats — different platforms, different adjudication
  5. Re-apply after relevant time windows if the issue was time-bound

Try Shipt for grocery delivery Target-owned. Delivers from Target, Meijer, Costco, Petco, Sephora, and many regional grocers. New members get a free trial. Try Shipt Free →

FAQ

Is Instacart easier or harder than DoorDash? Different. Instacart is harder per-order (more cognitive load, more time) but pays more per-order. DoorDash is easier per-order but you need more deliveries to match Instacart’s hourly throughput.

Do I need to know the grocery store layout? You’ll learn it. The app provides item-finding hints, and customers can sometimes communicate. The first few orders at a new store are slower.

What about substitutions? This is one of Instacart’s harder aspects. When an item is out of stock, you have options: pick a similar item (the app shows suggestions), message the customer, or refund the item. Each path has trade-offs and affects the customer’s tip behavior.

Can I do Instacart on a bike? Generally no for full-service. The volume of groceries usually requires a car. In specific dense urban areas, bike or scooter shoppers exist for small orders.

How does Instacart’s pay compare to DoorDash hourly? Mixed. Per-order, Instacart usually pays more. Per-hour, the math depends on your shopping speed and order availability. Many shoppers report hourly comparable to DoorDash; some higher; some lower.

Will Instacart give me a 1099 at tax time? Yes, full-service shoppers (1099 contractors) get a 1099 if earning $600+. In-store shoppers (W-2 employees in some markets) get a W-2. See How to Get Your DoorDash 1099-NEC Tax Form for the parallel 1099 process.

What does the Instacart payment card do? Full-service shoppers get a card to pay for groceries at the store. The card is funded by Instacart specifically for the customer’s order. You don’t pay out of pocket and get reimbursed later — the card handles it directly.

What if the store doesn’t have an item? Use the substitution flow in the app, message the customer, or mark as out of stock. Each option is normal; just handle it correctly.

Is Instacart safe? Comparable safety to other gig delivery work. Most time is inside grocery stores; the driving portion has standard delivery-driver risks.

Can I do Instacart and DoorDash simultaneously? Hard during an Instacart order (you’re in a store). Easier between orders. Most shoppers segment their time rather than simultaneous multi-app.

Related reading: